This is a fully loaded edition and the supplements are of the quantity and quality one would expect from Criterion, but we admittedly havenít seen for a long while. All supplements are found on the first disc.
Some do come from Sonyís previous 2001 DVD edition starting with an audio commentary by Richard Schickel and Jeff Young. Itís a decent enough track with the two talking about the various aspects of the film, from its presentation of its characters and people, to the long history of the production, and to the performances, specifically Brandoís and the impact he had. Unfortunately the two constantly get caught up on the House of Un-American Activities Committee and Kazanís testimony before them, where he ďnamed names.Ē Of course one expects this subject to come up: whether Kazan intended it or not the film, made immediately afterwards, has a storyline that could be seen as a comment or defense of that incident, but the subject keeps coming up and the track can lose its focus as the two get caught up in talking about the morality of what Kazan did. In all itís not a terrible track, but some comments in it contradict other statements found in the other supplements (like the glove scene,) and most of the information is repeated elsewhere, so listening to it is not all that necessary.
Following this is a new 17-minute conversation between Martin Scorsese and Kent Jones. Jones doesnít have much of a purpose other than to ask questions of Scorsese and nod in agreement with the director every once in a while. Scorsese talks about the impact On the Waterfront had on him when he first saw it and how heavy an influence it was in his directing career, particularly the realism found within it. He also talks about other films of the period along with Brando and ďmethod actingĒ, which leads to Scorsese to talk about John Garfield to an extent. Though Iím really not sure why Jones is there Scorsese offers a lot and makes the supplement a rather fascinating inclusion.
Elia Kazan: An Outisder is a 53-minute documentary on the director made in 1983. Itís basically a conversation with Kazan and his career, skimping over early theater work and then the development of The Actors Studio and ďThe MethodĒ which is where Robert De Niro shows up for a bit to talk about Kazan. Kazan then revisits the pier where On the Waterfront was shot and he talks about the film. Here he also talks about his testimony in front of HUAC and explains why he did what he did. From here Kazan then talks about casting, his love of writing, James Dean, theater, and then his own family. Itís surprisingly brisk and anyone interested in the director and his career will find this a worthwhile feature to go through.
ĒIím Standiní Over Here NowĒ is a new 45-minute documentary on the filmís production put together by Criterion. It features interviews with authors Leo Brandy, Victor Navasky, and Lisa Dombrowski, Cineaste editor Dan Georgankas, and film scholar David Thomson. The piece basically summarizes all previous features, with the participants going over Kazanís history, his testimony before HUAC, and then cover the production history of On the Waterfront. They go over the development of the script, getting the funds for the film, casting (as mentioned elsewhere Frank Sinatra was originally considered for the role of Terry Malloy) and the filmís release. The participants also talk about many aspects of the film itself, looking at all of the performances, focus on how certain scenes play, and then also talk about whether the film was a response to the reaction that occurred after Kazan testified. Typical talking-heads documentary but it covers most of the material found in the commentary and I actually preferred it to that feature.
Criterion has also managed to get a new interview with Eva Marie Saint, who made her movie debut with On the Waterfront. The actress talks about getting the role and what it was like working with Brando and Kazan. She talks about the ďglove sceneĒ mentioned in just about every other feature in this set, but contradicts most saying the scene was not born on the spot but was rather born after a mistake during rehearsal. She also recalls some of the dangers, particularly the alley scene involving the truck, which came close to hitting her and Brando. She recalls the Oscars (she mentally noted all of the people who didnít clap when Kazan won) and then talks about how different it was to work with Alfred Hitchcock afterwards. Itís an absolutely wonderful interview thatís only fault is that itís a short 11-minutes.
Also taken from the original Sony DVD is a 2001 interview with Elia Kazan. The 12-minute interview basically sums up most everything weíve seen and heard before in previous features about the filmís production, but Kazan goes into great detail about the ďcontenderĒ scene in the cab. For this aspect the feature is another worthwhile addition.
A rather thoughtful inclusion, and something only Criterion would do, is a 12-minute interview with longshoreman Thomas Hanley, who also played the kid Tommy Collins in the film. Hanley recalls how he came to get the role and talks fondly of Brando, who he considered a regular guy. The most interesting aspect of the interview turns out to be his firsthand accounts of what it was like to work on the waterfront and the gang activity that occurred there. He talks about the code of silence and the crimes that occurred. He admits he followed many of the same codes mentioned in the film but in later years stopped adhering to it. He amusingly closes talking about how heís glad that most of the gangsters from that time are in jail and heís now waiting for the latest batch to also go to jail. A rather fascinating interview and yet another great addition.
Who is Mr. Big? is a 25-minute interview with author James T. Fisher who talks about the real waterfront that influenced the film and the various people the characters in the film are based on. Ultimately it offers a lot of historical information that proves absolutely fascinating but Fisher, somewhat humourously, seems to forget to catch his breath while talking.
Contender: Mastering the Method is a 25-minute feature from the previous Sony DVD and features Richard Schickel, James Lipton, Patricia Bosworth, Jeff Young, and actors Rod Steiger and Martin Landau talking about the famous scene between Brando and Steiger in the cab. Kazan famously just let the scene play out, doing very little ďdirectingĒ and both Steiger and Brando took the scene in a completely different direction than other people figured it would go, with it playing more like a love scene than a scene of anger. Here the participants break down the scene in great detail pointing out every little nuance, with a good chunk of it devoted to Brandoís gesture in moving a gun away. Steiger also recalls firsthand how the scene developed and a nervousness that built in him as he played out the scene with Brando. A surprisingly decent examination of the filmís most famous scene.
Criterion then includes a new visual essay about Leonard Bernstein and his score for the film. The 20-minute piece goes over how the composer came to be involved with the production (who agreed to do it as long as he could also do a concert suite based off of it) and then goes over the various cues and the scenes they play over. Itís surprisingly in-depth and nicely breaks down many of the scoreís moments.
Criterion then goes over the various aspect ratios the film has been shown in. The interesting 5-minute feature gives a brief history of the widescreen format and why Columbia chose to show the film (and others) theatrically in various ratios. It then compares many sequences between the three provided here (1.33:1, 1.66:1, and 1.85:1) and points out the advantages and disadvantages.
The disc then closes with the filmís theatrical trailer.
Disc two presents the 1.33:1 and 1.85:1 versions of the film. Each version also comes with the choice of a PCM 1.0 mono track, or the remixed DTS-HD MA 5.1 surround track. The commentary is not included and no other features appear on the disc.
The set then concludes with a 45-page booklet featuring an essay by Michael Almereyda followed by a reprint of Elia Kazanís statement on why he testified and ďnamed names.Ē It also includes a reprint of the 1948 news article written by Malcolm Johnson about the corruption on the docks, which ultimately influenced the film, and then a reprint of the 1953 article by Budd Shulberg about Father John Corridan, who was the basis for the character of Father Pete Barry (Karl Malden) in the film. Overall a fantastic booklet, the article by Johnson proving to be the most intriguing of the bunch.
In all, despite some repetition in places, I think Criterion has nicely rounded out the supplements. It gives a good dose of contextualization, some wonderful analysis and insights, and a great look at the production, Brando, and Kazan. Probably the best set Criterion has put together in a while. 10/10