The Criterion Collection presents Jean-Luc Godardís Vivre sa vie in its original aspect ratio of 1.33:1 on this dual-layer disc. The image has unfortunately been window boxed.
Taken from the same high-def transfer used for the Blu-ray, the DVD looks rather good but nowhere near as good as the Blu-ray. Detail is fairly distinct, presenting patterns in clothing rather well, along with details in the faces of the characters (the footage from The Passion of Joan of Arc presented here might actually look better than whatís on Criterionís DVD of that film.) Contrast is sharp, presenting solid whites and grays with some fairly deep blacks. Compression artifacts are noticeable, especially in darker scenes, and edge-enhancement can make an appearance.
The print used presents very little in the way of damage, a spec of debris here and there, along with some moments of the film can look a touch soft, and flickering does occur, but as a whole itís been cleaned up.
Despite some issues with the transfer I thought it looked quite good, but it has to be said that the Blu-ray edition is better. Some of Criterionís DVDs can hold their own against their Blu-ray counterpart but this is a clear case where the high-def release towers over the DVD. 8/10
All DVD screen captures are presented in their original size from the source disc. Images have been compressed slightly to conserve space. While they are not exact representations they should offer a general idea of overall video quality.
Criterionís DVD and Blu-ray editions are fairly solid in the way of supplements.
First is an audio commentary by film scholar Adrian Martin, ported over from the Australian DVD release, similar to the Criterion DVD of 2 or 3 Things I Know About Her, and like his track for that film this is another excellent scholarly recording. He of course examines Godardís style and his ďbreaking the rulesĒ of conventional cinema, breaks down the fragmented narrative, and likes to mention how Godard makes use of constrained space for certain shots. He touches on the filmís themes of freedom and constraint, pointing at that, like it has been mentioned with Renoir, windows represent a possible freedom. He also of course goes into detail on Godardís interest in prostitution which is based more on the money and selling of oneself, and then brings up Godardís use of music, calling him the ďgreatest D.J. of film music.Ē Though I think I would rank his commentary for 2 or 3 Things I Know About Her higher, this is still a rather good one, worth popping on. As a side note, the commentaryís text description states the track was recorded in 2001, which is a mistake. It would have been recorded in 2006 as Martin mentions the death of longtime Godard editor AgnŤs Guillemot, who died in December of 2005, and also mentions Mathieu Kassovitzís 2003 film Gothika (and if youíre wondering how that film could be mentioned in a commentary for a Godard film itís only because Mathieuís father, Peter Kassovitz, is in Vivre sa vie.) Not a problem at all, but thought it was worth noting.
Next is a 45-minute interview with film scholar Jean Narboni that was recorded in 2004 and I assume was made for another DVD release. Itís a bit frustrating as half of the segment is constantly interrupted by clips from the film, and Iím pretty sure half of the feature is simply just clips while the other half is taken up by Narboni. It covers some of the same ground as the Martin commentary but does add some additional insight into Godardís analysis of prostitution throughout a lot of his films, even if theyíre casually mentioned in some way. He breaks down the film as a portrait, even managing to bring up the Stations of the Cross, and also has a somewhat brief anecdote about his first screening of the film where an Ignatius J. Reilly type was in attendance, only there to further prove to himself just how awful Godard really was. Despite some decent insight Iíd recommend the commentary over this if one was to choose only a single scholarly feature on here, as the constant cutting to clips make it a little annoying to go through.
The next feature, called Cinťmapanorama: Anna Karina, is actually a very candid and charming 11-minute interview with the actress, filmed for television in April of 1962 a few months before the release of Vivre sa vie. She doesnít talk about the film in particular, or any other film really, but talks a bit about first moving to France and her early experience in the country, and how she got her lucky break. She also seems to work hard at dispelling the myth about how she and Godard eventually got together which was that she responded to an ad that was a sort of casting call, people constantly calling her out on it. She was obviously hurt by certain remarks and seems determined to set the record straight here. But sheís quite charming, with a nice laugh, and itís actually hard not to sort of fall for her here.
And of course it wouldnít be a complete set of supplements if we didnít get something about prostitution in France at the time on here, and Criterion delivers with Faire Face: La prostitution, a 1961 exposť on the problem. Though a touch trashy itís actually fairly fascinating and Iím disappointed that Criterion has obviously trimmed it down, presenting only 22-minutes of it with obvious cuts. It includes interviews with prostitutes, current and former, all of whom are shrouded in shadow to conceal their identities, and they talk about how they got into the business, with one getting into great detail about her life over the years and how she finally got out of the business. Thereís discussion with police and various experts on its place in society and they push for more controls, including medical testing. Thereís also a great amount of detail about the pimps and how they turn women. I assume this isnít the only French piece on prostitution but Iíll wager a guess that Criterion went with this one because Judge Marcel Sarcotte, who wrote the book that prodded Godard into making Vivre sa vie, is one of the interview subjects. Though it really feels like something that could be shown on Dateline complete with Chris Hanson narration it was rather interesting and certainly worth viewing.
Oý en est: La Prostitution is a very brief section on the book by Marcel Sarcotte that went on to inspire the film. It has been divided into two sections. First is an excerpt from an essay by James Williams, who covers the connection between the film and the book. Itís an interesting read, though I question why Criterion didnít just include it in the booklet. It really is just a few pages of text notes that you navigate through using the remote. One area where this DVD does better the Blu-ray is the text size for this feature, which is much bigger and easier to read here when compared to the BD edition, though it could be just me. The next section presents photos of the actual book, focusing on the photos within that book (so in essence theyíre photos of the photos in the book.) But thatís unfortunately it for details about the book. I was actually hoping for more on the book but what we get is better than nothing at all.
The supplements then close with Godardís fairly playful theatrical trailer for the film.
The wonderful booklet that comes with this edition also includes a few goodies. It contains the reprinted text from the ad Godard took out for the film, shown also in the Narboni interview, along with the scenario by Godard that was printed in Film Comment in 1962. It then contains a short but good essay on the film by Michael Atkinson and then moves on to a couple of interviews with Godard on the film from Sight & Sound and Cahiers du cinťma. Thereís also a reprinting of an excellent article on Godardís sound recording for the film that first appeared in La revue du son in 1962. As usual Criterionís booklet is worth going through, closing off the release nicely.
Not jam packed but itís full of interesting material, the only bust probably being the interview with Narboni, but that has more to do with presentation. Still, itís a lovely and insightful collection of supplements that I think most will enjoy going through. 8/10