I wasn't saying that all releases are short on features, just that some could have made stellar 2 (blu-ray) disc packages, while other releases with nice features seemed to lower the bit rate to cram them onto a single disc.
MichaelB wrote:Marketa Lazarová's extras were fine - not the least bit "sparse".
This is the one I was most disappointed with as it presented a really good opportunity for a stacked package. Extras could have easily been expanded for a second disc of extras, while leaving the first disc to max out bit rate, commentaries & trailer. There could have been a documentary on the book itself, its author and the difficulty of translating it into other languages, as well as its historical importance. I do believe a lot of the story & film gets lost on contemporary audiences not familiar w/ history of Europe or of Christianity. Interviews with those now translating it into English & challenges they had would be nice. A more comprehensive/career-spanning doc on Vlacil also would have been nice & his relation to Czech new wave. Also absent is any of the documentaries on the career of Zdenek Liska since his music is so integral to the film & not widely available.
matrixschmatrix wrote:I bemoan Criterion's increasingly sparse commentaries a lot but the Rossellini/Bergman box is one of the best things they've put out in a long time, it is thoroughly and gorgeously stacked.
Yes this is contender for best features for 2013 award, but it's the reverse problem: reducing the bit rate to fit 2 very similar versions of the same film (plus extras) onto the same disc. Maybe it's the prints used, but I only have a 46" screen &
Journey to Italy does look better than the other 2 on my tv, same way I felt about the TV vs film version of
Fanny & Alexander, though not quite as dramatic.
I do like extras, but I like them to be educational, truly informative (which Criterion usually does a better job of doing than any one else), but my preference is for maximum a/v quality over their inclusion as I tend not to revisit them. It just seems to me that in older (dvd-only) days Criterion wouldn't hesitate as much to move stuff to a second disc to max out the feature on the first, but now with dual-format & or blu-ray (more expensive to manufacture?) they seem more hesitant.