They're only related as much as say, the various Chandler adaptions (and in the case of Return..., even less than that): they may all be based off the same source texts, but you wouldn't seriously argue that Hawks film is meant as a prequel to the Dmytryk?Nothing wrote:The first season of Lonesome Dove is 6hrs long. There is then Return to Lonesome Dove, Lonesome Dove: The Outlaw Years, Streets of Laredo, Dead Man's Walk... All part of a series.
I think a part of the dispute here is the very different conceptions of serialized TV in the U.S. and Britain. Here the division between a series and a miniseries are much more clearly defined than in Britain, where really, all that seems to separate the two is whether a second serial is commissioned. It seems largely touch and go. Look at State of Play (to give a more obvious example): according to our rules and IMDB, it is eligible. This despite the fact a second series was ordered, which would have made it ineligible. The simple fact that the second series never materialized is all that's separating it. Here on the other hand, something like Terriers, despite being cancelled after one season, is not eligible (nor should it be): the intention to make a long-running series as opposed to a self-contained miniseries was there from the outset.
Likewise, I guess something like The Day Today could be accepted for the 90s list, despite the fact that no one here is really going to make the argument for it as "cinema". Likewise, one could make an argument for pilot episodes of American series, many of which are self-contained, and in many cases in the past, when a series isn't picked up, are released as standalone films.
Milch may have chosen to keep the first season self-contained, but there was no doubting that if given the chance, he would have kept the series going. It is not a miniseries. It wasn't conceived nor produced as one. Jean-Pierre Gorin may very well be right about The Wire, but the line needs to be drawn somewhere, and if that means shortshrifting it, I'm okay with that. At the end of the day, its just a silly list.