criterionforum.org

I can't find you, Fop, what's your fb handle?

Matt wrote:

Ben Cheshire on Facebook wrote:I didn't know Criterion had any Lubitsch

Are you kidding me? That's strictly amateur hour.

Oops, I did know that. I've got two on my want list. I heard Trouble in Paradise was one of their worst transfers; shame, its one of my favourite films.

Ben Cheshire wrote:I heard Trouble in Paradise was one of their worst transfers; shame, its one of my favourite films.

It's not a bad transfer, it's just that the film elements are in bad shape and there's not much that can be done about it. It's a good disc with an excellent commentary.

I'm Mark Ayala. I just removed my kitten photo. The last thing I posted on was their link to Wim Wenders' treament for Wings of Desire.

The Elegant Dandy Fop wrote:I'm Mark Ayala. I just removed my kitten photo.

Heh. And here I was, scrolling down in search of a promised panoply of kittens.

LQ wrote:

The Elegant Dandy Fop wrote:I'm Mark Ayala. I just removed my kitten photo.

Heh. And here I was, scrolling down in search of a promised panoply of kittens.

If you check now, it's my neighbor's morbidly obese cat laying down on a table. Still adorable.

Ben Cheshire wrote:Is CaptVeg Brandon from HTF?

Yep.

Matt wrote:

Ben Cheshire wrote:I heard Trouble in Paradise was one of their worst transfers; shame, its one of my favourite films.

It's not a bad transfer, it's just that the film elements are in bad shape and there's not much that can be done about it. It's a good disc with an excellent commentary.

I think the Criterion is far too dark, at least in the night scenes. In the (very important) opening image, I can barely make out that the dog is standing with its front paws on top of the rubbish bin. I have an off-air VHS in which this is absolutely clear. No doubt Criterion did their best with what Universal supplied, but it would appear that better - certainly brighter - elements survive (unless they've been lost since the 1980s broadcast!)

Matt wrote:

Ben Cheshire wrote:I heard Trouble in Paradise was one of their worst transfers; shame, its one of my favourite films.

It's not a bad transfer, it's just that the film elements are in bad shape and there's not much that can be done about it. It's a good disc with an excellent commentary.

Actually, that's what I heard too, so you're right, not a bad transfer, just weak elements.

On Facebook:
Question

Mother, Golden Demon, Westfront 1918, Gate of Hell - any chance of Criterion editions?

Response:

Yup.

Also from Facebook, in regard to Mädchen in Uniform...an Essential Art House release.

On Facebook.

I wrote:Do you have any plans for more Kon Ichikawa?

Criterion wrote:Yes.

So that's good news.

I wrote:Are we getting another Eclipse volume of Rossellini history films? Vol. 1 was the bee's knees!

Criterion wrote:So glad you thought so. Please help us spread the word! We'll get to the ancient world as soon as we solve the riddle of the Age of the Apostles.

looks like they would also like to do a Blu Ray of Ozu's Good Morning (doesn't mean they are though)... I liked Good Morning, but there are a few other Ozu's I would prefer to debut on Blu.

solaris72 wrote:

I wrote:Are we getting another Eclipse volume of Rossellini history films? Vol. 1 was the bee's knees!

Criterion wrote:So glad you thought so. Please help us spread the word! We'll get to the ancient world as soon as we solve the riddle of the Age of the Apostles.

Forgive me for begin green, but what might the riddle be? I've not seen the film(s). Maybe how to release them? As an Eclipse set or as a multi-disc mainline release?

aox wrote:looks like they would also like to do a Blu Ray of Ozu's Good Morning (doesn't mean they are though)... I liked Good Morning, but there are a few other Ozu's I would prefer to debut on Blu.

Good Morning is in dire need of a re-release, though, and if they are doing that, it makes sense to do a Blu-ray version too.

planetjake wrote:Forgive me for begin green, but what might the riddle be? I've not seen the film(s). Maybe how to release them? As an Eclipse set or as a multi-disc mainline release?

If Acts of the Apostles ever works out, it will likely be part of an Eclipse release ("Rossellini's History Films: The Ancient World") with Socrates and Augustine of Hippo. Criterion already licensed the rights to the latter two as part of a package with the other Rossellini TV titles, but has been unable to determine who the proper owner to the copyright of Acts of the Apostles is. Nobody has claimed it. That's the riddle.

Jeff wrote:

planetjake wrote:Forgive me for begin green, but what might the riddle be? I've not seen the film(s). Maybe how to release them? As an Eclipse set or as a multi-disc mainline release?

If Acts of the Apostles ever works out, it will likely be part of an Eclipse release ("Rossellini's History Films: The Ancient World") with Socrates and Augustine of Hippo. Criterion already licensed the rights to the latter two as part of a package with the other Rossellini TV titles, but has been unable to determine who the proper owner to the copyright of Acts of the Apostles is. Nobody has claimed it. That's the riddle.

If no one claims it, they should keep a paper record of their search, include a note in the set that they looked and will be glad to talk with anyone who claims it, and release it.

Peter Becker: "Hey guys, waddaya say we set ourselves up for a copyright infringement lawsuit that could ruin us!?"

Criterion staff: "YEAH!!!!WOO!!!!!"

You don't think very hard, do you?

aox wrote:looks like they would also like to do a Blu Ray of Ozu's Good Morning (doesn't mean they are though)... I liked Good Morning, but there are a few other Ozu's I would prefer to debut on Blu.

Ahahahaha if they did a whole new level of proper color for Ozu begins... On HD! Hm don't think they'd really tweak the colors of their Asian film on Blu.

Jeff wrote:

planetjake wrote:Forgive me for begin green, but what might the riddle be? I've not seen the film(s). Maybe how to release them? As an Eclipse set or as a multi-disc mainline release?

If Acts of the Apostles ever works out, it will likely be part of an Eclipse release ("Rossellini's History Films: The Ancient World") with Socrates and Augustine of Hippo. Criterion already licensed the rights to the latter two as part of a package with the other Rossellini TV titles, but has been unable to determine who the proper owner to the copyright of Acts of the Apostles is. Nobody has claimed it. That's the riddle.

Also Acts of the Apostles in five parts runs 341 minutes, while Socrates and Augustine of Hippo run 120 and 117 minutes respectively - I suppose the former could just fit on 2 discs (3 discs much more preferable) while the latter two would be comfortably accomodated on single discs each - once that rights issue is sorted they all would make a similar set to the first Rossellini History Films...

Matt wrote:

aox wrote:looks like they would also like to do a Blu Ray of Ozu's Good Morning (doesn't mean they are though)... I liked Good Morning, but there are a few other Ozu's I would prefer to debut on Blu.

Good Morning is in dire need of a re-release, though, and if they are doing that, it makes sense to do a Blu-ray version too.

certainly. I didn't mean to imply otherwise. I was merely declaring my selfish interests. :-"

What I would give for a Blu of An Autumn Afternoon.

I'd hold my breath on Ozu on Blu. Maybe if we lucky, we get Tokyo Story.

If they eventually revisit Tokyo Story on Blu with a new restoration (aren't the Japanese working on a resto already for some time?), they better rerelease it on DVD simultaneously - unlike 8 1/2, there is definite room for improvement on the Ozu.

Matt wrote:

aox wrote:looks like they would also like to do a Blu Ray of Ozu's Good Morning (doesn't mean they are though)... I liked Good Morning, but there are a few other Ozu's I would prefer to debut on Blu.

Good Morning is in dire need of a re-release, though, and if they are doing that, it makes sense to do a Blu-ray version too.

so I should hold off on buying that? there's plenty of other titles on my wishlist...but that was one i was considering picking up in the B&N sale. Is it that bad?

It's that orange. Since there's a chance they're going to restore it I'd go with something else, for now.

There is a decent transfer of GOOD MORNING, far superior to the Criterion, complete with Eng subs, in Vol #3 of the Tartan Ozu sets (obviously R2 PAL) still available here...