domino harvey wrote:No, Comes a Horseman is a huge zero of a movie. I know, I was once like you and thought it had to have value given the pedigree in front of and behind the camera, but nah. Re: later Pakula, Rollover is racist garbage (though prescient and of its time, so of some contextual value maybe-- it is handily the worst Pakula film I've seen), Pelican Brief is a lowkey but pretty good Grisham adaptation that doubles as a pre-YouTube supercut of Julia Roberts running, and Starting Over, scripted by James L Brooks, is hilarious and wonderful (and I am contractually obligated to bring up that Candice Bergen has the funniest seduction scene in film history)
Thanks, I'll definitely seek out
Starting Over. (And probably
Rollover, too, just because I've heard so much hushed, enthused chatter about it that I can't resist). Pakula's gift with actors makes me think a Pakula comedy could be pretty successful.
I recall Steven Bach's
Final Cut opening with an amusing anecdote about basically how depressing it was, as an exec at UA, to witness the dreary anti-reaction to the first few showings of
Horseman. And on further thought the idea of a Pakula Western has always seemed inherently "off" to me, which is why my hopes for the film always rested on Willis's shoulders.
Since we all seem to agree Pakula's a talented director, does anyone have a theory as to what happened to him? Most of the great New Hollywood auteurs dropped off in the 80s/90s, sure, but most at least managed a couple great films after the decline, if not an outright "comeback" a la Altman. Why not Pakula? Did his tastes just lead him astray, perhaps? (In addition to the usual difficulty of getting an intelligent adult-targeted picture made, post-
Heaven's Gate.)