Boosmahn wrote:A faithful adaptation of Jeffrey Eugenides’s popular first novel,...
Isn't there a slight departure between the two? I've heard that while the film focuses more on the girls themselves, the book is more mystery-centric and tends to spend more time with the group of boys. Can anyone comment on this?
Giovanni Ribisi should have got an Oscar nomination for the narration of the movie and I'm a bit disappointing that he does not appear in an audio commentary (although I remember that there are some funny stories by Sofia Coppola such as Josh Harnett wig). Giovanni really added a bitterness, almost desperate tone to the movie...
so that it could even matched the last poem from Nicolas Roeg's "Walkabout":
"
Into my heart an air that kills
From yon far country blows:
What are those blue remembered hills,
What spires, what farms are those?
That is the land of lost content,
I see it shining plain,
The happy highways where I went
And cannot come again."
At that point the boys are to the verge of "Suicide" too - still alive, adult but away from their life. There's no turning back.
Remember the scene (it's not explicit) where Josh Hartnett character, now in a psychiatric hospital seems totally under the charmed of Lux now. It was also smart for Sofia Coppola that she casts another "pretty face" from the 80's to play this character in that scene (Michael Paré - the John Wayne of the 80's (remember Streets Of Fire ?)
Thus, IMHO, Sofia (I think that she was helped by her father for the script) added another point of view : which makes now, in comparison to the book, makes this movie much more from the boys point of view - it kind of reminds me "Picnic at Hanging-Rock"... So, I have the feeling that Sofia Coppola leads 2 points of view (not antagonist) : the young girls, and the boys now became adult and still haunted and hooked by the past and this girl... Not because of the trauma, but they seem to have reached the same pre-nostalgia "syndrome" than the "virgin suicides" (but not because of religious, but job, routine, discovering what adult life is). That's what I found different from the novel, and makes the religious oppression more explicit in Picnic at Hanging-rock than in Virgin Suicide (for instance James Woods character looks more "lost" than oppressive...)
While this is not my favorite S.Coppola movie (Lost In Translation and Marie Antoinette), it totally hooked me when I discovered Kirsten Dunst

with this movie (I remember going into theatrical release to see her in Spiderman just because of this movie and rented all the movies she did at that time (and there was some masterpieces :-# ).
One great thing - but because of (c) rights that would not have been possible - would have been to have an isolated soundtrack just like the Twilight Time release: because the AIR soundtrack is fantastic (not mentioning for instance "Magic Man" by Heart). AIR disappointed me later, but at that time that was awesome like rock-prog bubble-gum ("Playground Love" was an amazing number) and a Criterion bonus featuring their live premiered of the soundtrack in the "
Morning becomes eclectic/Le matin devient éclectique" would have been an awesome bonus.
I'm happy that they included "
Playground Love" clip since it contains movie outtakes in the classroom
basically it seems that there is all the bonus of the DVD Pathé release and the Blu-Ray Pathé release (the short movie).
speaking of video-clips in order to be completist, they could have added Sofia Coppola's black & white video clip of "
I Don't Know What To Do With Myself". That would have been a very nice "welcoming" to Kate Moss doing a lap dance sequence in gorgeous black and white in the Criterion collection.
Fortunately the X4 transfer will be an improvement over the Blu-Ray Pathé which was an old scan with a kind of "voile"/moiré artefacts over the screen - which really doesn't belong to the original photography.
I would have loved the outtakes of the 8mm imaginary "home holiday movies" of Lux and her sisters...