I laughed:dwk wrote: Wed Jul 10, 2019 3:39 pm Hard Case Crime to publish a novel written by De Palma and Susan Lehman

I laughed:dwk wrote: Wed Jul 10, 2019 3:39 pm Hard Case Crime to publish a novel written by De Palma and Susan Lehman

I can imagine watching this movie and thinking, "I could do this better," but what in the material compelled him to actually be passionate enough to follow through on such idle thoughts?!domino harvey wrote: Mon Jun 15, 2015 3:20 pm Palmetto (Volker Schlöndorff 1998) Tonally wonky and inspired more by 80s interpretations of noir than the real thing, this nevertheless has some component parts that work. Woody Harrelson plays one of the dumbest noir protagonists ever, and the film to its credit doesn't confuse his almost non-stop stream of mistakes and idiocies for anything other than what they are. It's no surprise that the source novel was called Just Another Sucker, because for a former reporter, Harrelson does everything wrong. The two female leads seem miscast and should have been switched: Elizabeth Shue plays the sexually voracious bad girl and Gina Gershon is the stay at home supportive good girl? Are you sure that's the choice you want to make here, movie? Though, to be fair, Shue overcompensates hilariously (intentionally so) by making her erotic come-ons so overblown and florid that at one point she mounts a wall and presents herself in a gloriously tasteless sequence that is one of the few moments the film really embraces its utter silliness. And the kidnapping plot at the heart of the film is dopey and predicated on Harrelson being as dumb as possible, which, based on the evidence, made it a safer bet than most convoluted noir plots!
DarkImbecile wrote: Wed Jul 10, 2019 4:39 pmI laughed:dwk wrote: Wed Jul 10, 2019 3:39 pm Hard Case Crime to publish a novel written by De Palma and Susan Lehman
![]()
That was just a split diopter joke, not claimed as a real excerpt
As a fan of both Mamet and De Palma, I have watched this movie several times in an attempt to like it. But I can't get there. It's clunky and silly despite some good scenes. I think the main problem (other than Costner's wooden performance) is that Mamet and De Palma are a poor match stylistically. Mamet's writing has a restrained, hit-the-beats quality that doesn't gel with De Palma's sensuous, exaggerated visual style. By comparison, Oliver Stone's script for Scarface works perfectly with De Palma's style.hearthesilence wrote: Fri May 14, 2021 11:05 pm Came across this Chicago Tribune feature Gene Siskel wrote on The Untouchables. It's not a great movie, but I kind of have a soft spot for it because it was a pretty big deal for anyone I know who was in Chicago when they filmed it (sort of like The Dark Knight when that filmed in Chicago, where suddenly you had a big Hollywood movie and big movie stars taking over the town). It goes into a lot of detail re: David Mamet's involvement and how his script alone more or less secured all the talent that came on board.