Leos Carax

Discuss individual directors, actors, cinematographers, writers, and more
Post Reply
Message
Author
User avatar
denti alligator
Joined: Thu Nov 04, 2004 1:36 am
Location: "born in heaven, raised in hell"

Re: Leos Carax

#151 Post by denti alligator »

A good friend of mine with impeccable taste says the three greatest novels in English are Ulysses, Moby Dick, and (drumroll) Pierre.

So not everyone thinks it’s horrible. And apparently the first 40-50 pages are not representative of the whole, since they were written to fulfill some serialization deal. He apparently gets fed up with it and starts sabotaging the novel, turning it into a kind of parody. But I’m speaking from what this friend told me 20 years ago. I still haven’t read it.
User avatar
Matt
Joined: Tue Nov 02, 2004 4:58 pm

Re: Leos Carax

#152 Post by Matt »

Hilarious, then, that I would read just up until the part where it actually gets better. My attention span for reading is shot these days, so there's no way I'll try again.
User avatar
Mr Sausage
Has Risen from the Grave
Joined: Thu Nov 04, 2004 1:02 am
Location: Canada

Re: Leos Carax

#153 Post by Mr Sausage »

I had a prof in grad school who was fascinated by the book, which is how I ended up reading it the first time. I’ve never been able to buy the idea that Pierre is a parody, although self-sabotaged seems about right. I also don’t find the first 50-ish pages that different, let alone worse, than the rest, although about halfway through the book Melville seemingly reconceives it and tries to turn the thing into a satire on the publishing industry, which ends up rendering the initial gothic story incoherent, among other problems. But even as reconceived the whole thing is still written in that turgid, overblown style that’s so tedious. If somehow you manage to like the style, maybe this would be a masterpiece for you. You certainly can’t read it for the story. Only two things happen in the first hundred pages.

I just don't understand the contingent who actually like this thing. It's impossible to get through without forcing yourself! Matt, I can't believe you would find any pleasures waiting for you in the rest of the book even if you did have the attention span to read it.
Stefan Andersson
Joined: Thu Nov 15, 2007 5:02 am

Re: Leos Carax

#154 Post by Stefan Andersson »

2026 article about Pierre:
https://www.sensesofcinema.com/2026/cte ... mbiguites/

Info from 2016 - TV version apparently ran 169 minutes (3 episodes: 61', 55', 53')
https://www.centrepompidou.fr/fr/progra ... nt/cXyGRq4

2012 Carax interview about Pierre:
https://www.telerama.fr/cinema/entretie ... ,83483.php

Update:
Pola X was apparently partly shot in Super 16:
https://www.pandorafilm.com/filmography/pola-x.html
Last edited by Stefan Andersson on Fri Aug 07, 2026 5:08 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Zot!
Joined: Wed Jan 20, 2010 4:09 am

Re: Leos Carax

#155 Post by Zot! »

I don’t even like Moby Dick which I also find turgid and overblown, but I’m not sure if any of this matters for Carax’s film adaptation, which to me has it’s own purpose and form.
User avatar
Rrobynne
Joined: Sat May 28, 2022 4:12 am

Re: Leos Carax

#156 Post by Rrobynne »

The Pola X restoration has its UK premiere this Sunday: https://www.ica.art/films/tfff-pola-x
It appears from the FNAC website that the release date of the new Carlotta release is 17th November, don't know if I'm allowed to link other boutique retailers here?
User avatar
domino harvey
Dot Com Dom
Joined: Wed Jan 11, 2006 6:42 pm

Re: Leos Carax

#157 Post by domino harvey »

Yes, no restrictions on links to retailers (so long as you are not sharing an affiliate link that garners you money for said click-throughs)
User avatar
Rrobynne
Joined: Sat May 28, 2022 4:12 am

Re: Leos Carax

#158 Post by Rrobynne »

Well, it's out now anyway - here's a PQ comparison: https://slow.pics/c/oJ9TweDQ
Very pleased the telecine of "Pierre..." comes out ahead of the old Pola X DVD! A punctuation mark at the end of the first century of cinema.
User avatar
Captain Paranoia
Joined: Thu Dec 28, 2023 12:33 am

Re: Leos Carax

#159 Post by Captain Paranoia »

Rrobynne wrote: Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:43 pm Well, it's out now anyway - here's a PQ comparison: https://slow.pics/c/oJ9TweDQ
Very pleased the telecine of "Pierre..." comes out ahead of the old Pola X DVD! A punctuation mark at the end of the first century of cinema.
It appears the Pierre cut on the BD seems to resembles the DVD in those images (although the DVD seems to have more information on the edges).

Could you list off the supplements on the discs? (and if there was material on the DVD was not ported over) And confirm if there are any English subtitles?
User avatar
Rrobynne
Joined: Sat May 28, 2022 4:12 am

Re: Leos Carax

#160 Post by Rrobynne »

Captain Paranoia wrote: Sat Nov 14, 2026 5:30 am
Rrobynne wrote: Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:43 pm Well, it's out now anyway - here's a PQ comparison: https://slow.pics/c/oJ9TweDQ
Very pleased the telecine of "Pierre..." comes out ahead of the old Pola X DVD! A punctuation mark at the end of the first century of cinema.
It appears the Pierre cut on the BD seems to resembles the DVD in those images (although the DVD seems to have more information on the edges).

Could you list off the supplements on the discs? (and if there was material on the DVD was not ported over) And confirm if there are any English subtitles?
No English subtitles on anything in the set. I'm mocking up a translation of the French SDH captions on the Pola X BD as we speak for my own viewing pleasure (not sure that sort of thing would be okay to link here, especially if Criterion get their hands on an English-language release deal in future) - although I note severe paraphrasing of some scenes in those French captions and am attempting to correct this.

I mentioned the apparent consistency in grade between the Pola X DVD and the Pierre... BD, versus the Pola X BD (which like the Criterion Boy Meets Girl, is much darker than previous releases) in my post over at bluray.com near the bottom of this thread: https://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread.ph ... st24511209

Contents of the 2026 FR Carlotta set:
-What I believe is a full reproduction of the contemporaneous press kit booklet for Pola X
-Mini-poster of both versions' key art

UHD
-Don't know, won't open in my Pioneer USB drive, but appears from internet listings to include Sans Titre in 4k as well as Pola X, + possibly replicates the special features on the Pola X BD, unclear on that point

BD 1
-Pola X (includes French AD audio track + 5.1 surround + stereo audio + French SDH captions, in France's standardised subtitling colour code)
-Sans Titre (no subs, but includes 5.1 surround + stereo audio)
-New interview with Frédéric Bonnaud, director of the Cinémathèque française
-New interview with Olivier Père, CEO of ARTE France Cinéma
-New interview with editor Nelly Quettier
-Contemporaneous Leos Carax interview (I believe it's the one on youtube where he talks about his fear of "imposture", ~30 mins length)
-Contemporaneous Leos Carax Cannes interview (the one where he's sat with the sea behind them, ~1h length)
-Theatrical trailer (the ~20 sec TV spots for Pola X, which can be found on Youtube, are not included on the set)
None

BD 2
-Pierre ou, les ambiguïtés, presented as its 3 separate episodes, with credits per episode unlike the leaked VHS recording which fades out at the end of the first two episodes (no subs, but includes 5.1 surround + stereo audio)
-No additional features

...

Contents of the ~2001 FR Pathé "Pola X" DVD:
-Pola X (stereo audio, English subs)
-"Musique et Chutes" featurette - a montage of behind-the-scenes footage and footage of Scott Walker present at the recording of the score
- "Deleted" scene from the Pierre... version, which was of course unavailable at the time, of Pierre singing karaoke
- Sans Titre
- 6 min extract of the 30 min Carax interview included on the Carlotta set
Post Reply