I think that's precisely the problem though: far too many people only seek out Criterion releases when there are plenty of labels (Criterion included!) doing great work right now. (No, I am obviously not referring to Kino.)Omensetter wrote: Thu Nov 19, 2026 3:00 am I would guess that if Criterion's is indeed a higher-profile version, then it's because Criterion is releasing it. Obviously, they have more of a reach. Plus, this version includes The Wind and The Scarlet Letter. If Criterion were to release The Crowd, then it would be a higher-profile release because it's from Criterion.
What's gonna kill physical media is a lack of curiosity and loyalty to only one single label. Period.
I believe I read somewhere Criterion were not interested in SUNRISE: A SONG OF TWO HUMANS at all, which is crazy given its acclaim?andyli wrote: Thu Nov 19, 2026 2:18 am It didn't snowball into anything. I just meant that we probably should wait a while and not jump to conclusions.
If anything Flicker Alley is the party that is worthy of support and acclaim for releasing important silent films. Criterion has not lead the charge for years (even decades). Getting ready to give us a nice Sjöström box won't overnight change their profile in this regard. For all the years that they left us wanting, they could probably wait a few months more for accolades, perhaps until the reviews are actually out.