1334 Wild at Heart

Discuss releases by Criterion and the films on them. Threads may contain spoilers!
Message
Author
User avatar
Mr Sausage
Has Risen from the Grave
Joined: Thu Nov 04, 2004 1:02 am
Location: Canada

Re: 1334 Wild at Heart

#26 Post by Mr Sausage »

Roger Ebert’s famous dislike of Blue Velvet can be traced back to an inability to accept the sincerity of the benevolent town scenes while being fully persuaded of the sincerity of the cruel and violent scenes. So the film became insincere for him and capsized from an imbalance. For a lot of modern people it’s a hard ask to get them believe in a purity of goodness, but you have to for Lynch’s dialectic to work: the abyss of evil is always set in stark contrast with sublime goodness, and that contrast of extreme states organizes his movies. It also becomes a kind of moral vision, either redemptive (with a lingering shadow) as in Blue Velvet and Fire Walk With Me, or despairing and critical as in Lost Highway and The Return. Mulholland Drive is the most melancholy and ambivalent of these moral visions, with neither the good or bad aspects of the narrative having a fuller expression than the other at the end. The final transcendent image of the film is at the same time profoundly sad and also sublime, a dual image of escape and entrapment. That the movie’s contraries build off each other throughout the story until finally merging is maybe why I find that movie especially satisfying.

My problem with Wild at Heart comes down to its insistence: it’s so insistent that you share its exaggerated vision of good and evil that it starts to feel like it’s trying to persuade you, that’s it’s making an argument, and that’s not what I want from Lynch. But I do admire the risk the movie takes in asking the audience to believe in the absolute sincerity of something so exaggerated and so absurd. Maybe Lynch felt that if a popular audience was willing to follow him on that dualistic vision in Twin Peaks, they may’ve be ready for the most full-throated possible expression of it.
Post Reply